Skip to main content

Why the door isn’t fully closed for Seth Trimble to make a shocking UNC return

This potential rule change within the NCAA could allow Seth Trimble another season of college eligibility.
North Carolina Tar Heels guard Seth Trimble (7) drives to the basket Thursday, March 19, 2026, during the NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament first round game against the VCU Rams at Bon Secours Wellness Arena in Greenville, South Carolina.
North Carolina Tar Heels guard Seth Trimble (7) drives to the basket Thursday, March 19, 2026, during the NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament first round game against the VCU Rams at Bon Secours Wellness Arena in Greenville, South Carolina. | Alex Martin/Greenville News / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The NCAA is making waves in regard to the latest rule change that they are widely considering making.

That rule focuses on the often-discussed eligibility guidelines, a definite gray area currently in college athletics. Most recently, the NCAA has toyed with the idea of a five-year eligibility window, which could go into effect this summer.

Of course, rule changes often lead to more questions that need clarity, as the one that was posed above could have major implications on programs as they build next year's rosters.

Are players who just completed their fourth season of eligibility going to be grandfathered in?

The door might not be closed on the Seth Trimble era at UNC

If this rule goes into effect this summer and players perceived to be done with their college careers are granted an additional season of eligibility, it will send major waves through the college basketball world.

North Carolina's prime (and lone) example is Seth Trimble, a four-year player for the Tar Heels who was a key contributor this past season. If he is granted another season of eligibility, would Trimble, who is known to love UNC and everything about Chapel Hill, consider coming back for a fifth season, especially if the NIL money is there?

You'd think he'd at least consider it.

For programs who are currently working the transfer portal to build next year's roster, the uncertainty of this ruling is not helpful, given that schools might shy away from recruiting certain players in hopes of bringing back a key star with added eligibility, while student-athletes who are evaluating their options in the transfer portal might be weary to commit to a school that might be able to bring back a player who fills a similiar position/role.

While the NCAA sorts through this potential rule change, Michael Malone and the Tar Heels need to operate based on what we know now. If the decision to apply this rule (while grandfathering in student-athletes) is something that is adopted, then, at that time, they can at least kick the tires to see if Trimble has any interest in returning.

If the rule goes into effect, the speculation will be on regarding a potential fifth year in Chapel Hill for one of the program's fan favorites.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations