UNC Vs. Duke: A Match-up of the Greatest Players in Each School’s History

by Basketball

With all of the attention surrounding the rivalry between UNC and Duke after their matchup last week, I felt as though the analysis should continue by comparing the best players that both schools have had in their storied histories. As opposed to a general player ranking list, this contest will be based on which team has the best players to fill a traditional lineup card (with a point guard, shooting guard, small forward, power forward, center, and two bench positions). In this matchup there is no chance that Duke comes away with a miracle last second victory. In fact, much to the delight of UNC fans, the Heels have a dominating advantage on their side: a player by the name of Michael Jeffery Jordan.

Photo Credit: Bob Donnan-US PRESSWIRE


UNC TARHEELS ALL-TIME ROSTER:

PG      Kenny Smith                                    PPG 12.2       APG 5.5         RPG 2.0

While Kenny Smith’s career was not the most impressive that we have ever seen from a point guard, his 4,073 assist make him the best that the Tar Heels have seen come through their school. He received the nickname “The Jet” for his impressive speed, which he was able to utilize during his 10 year career. While a plethora of talented point guards during his time did not allow Smith to make an All-Star appearance, he was able to win two NBA Championships during his career. Smith now uses his in depth knowledge of the game as a famous analyst and broadcaster.

SG      Michael Jordan                               PPG 28.3       APG 4.9         RPG 4.9

The UNC Tar Heels have an advantage that no other basketball team in the country can stake claim to. They have the best player to ever play the game. Michael Jordan is hands down the greatest talent to ever take the court, and his accomplishments speak for themselves. “Air Jordan” is a six time NBA Champion, six time Finals MVP, five time NBA MVP, and 14 time All-Star. He also has a NCAA Division I National Championship to his credit, along with countless other accolades. While it would take an entire book to list all that Jordan has meant to the game of basketball, I will simply let his iconic name speak for itself.

SF       Vince Carter                                     PPG 21.9       APG 4.0         RPG 4.0

Vince Carter has compiled a legendary basketball career not only for his exceptional scoring ability, but for his amazing athleticism. Carter is regarded by many (including myself) as the best dunker in the history of the sport. He has made a name for himself with a vast array of gravity defying dunks and high flying playmaking abilities. He is an eight time NBA All-Star, former Rookie of the Year (in 1999), and won the only NBA Dunk Contest in which he competed in 2000.

PF       Bob McAdoo                                   PPG 22.1       BPG 1.5         RPG 9.4

Bob McAdoo is a player that you have to look back to the 1970’s to remember. While his career was not as recent as the other players on this list, McAdoo has perhaps compiled the most impressive career in history for a UNC big man. While he was a bit undersized for a center (standing at 6-9) McAdoo was still able to establish himself as a dominate rebounder. During his career, he won two NBA titles and was a five time All-Star, while adding a league MVP and Rookie of the year award to his resume.

C         Rasheed Wallace                           PPG 14.6       BPG 1.3         RPG 6.7

Rasheed Wallace was able to put up a great career during his playing days, but is a player that I have always felt was unable to reach his full potential. Wallace used his tremendous size and length to become one of the best low post scorers and defenders of his time. That in combination with his excellent shooting ability (he had a .337 three point shooting percentage during his NBA career) made Wallace impossible to guard. However, due to his noted attitude issues (Wallace holds the all-time records for most technical fouls as a player and most technical fouls in a single season) he was never able to dominate in the same way the a player like Kareem Abdual Jabbar or Michael Jordan. While he was still able to win an NBA title and play in four All-Star games, I can’t help but wonder what he could have been.

BN      James Worthy (SF)                        PPG 17.6       APG 3.0         RPG 5.1

During a career in which he compiled three NBA Championships, one NCAA Division I Championship, and seven NBA All-Star appearances, James Worthy has undoubtedly established himself as one of the all-time greats.

BN      Antawn Jamison (PF)                    PPG 19.6       BPG 0.4         RPG 7.9

Antawn Jamison is known around the NBA for being a great scorer and rebounder. However, it is the odd manner in which he scores his points that draws the most attention. His unique array of behind the back hook shots and one handed floaters off the backboard have allowed him to go to two All-Star games and win the 2006 Sixth Man of the Year award.

 Duke’s all time roster plus my take on how this game would turn out after the break

1 2 >>

Follow Me on Pinterest

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments
Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest
ToddGreene 15 pts

I'm sure we could go on ad nauseum, and it's all conjecture. However, Lennie Rosenbluth played in a very different time. And if we are considering whole bodies of work here, college and pro, Sleepy Sam Perkins gets the nod at PF.

KIH Matt 37 pts moderator

ToddGreene

very true. I was shocked that Lenny is just now this year getting inducted into the North Carolina sports HOF.

ToddGreene 15 pts

@KIH Matt They showed Lennie yesterday when Barnes drew the seventh foul on Clemson. He turned his wife and said "that's 1 and 1". Is that guy still sharp or what. I hope I'm not drooling in my tapioca when I get to 50. I think he's pushing 80. Wow!

KIH Matt 37 pts moderator

I think all the players Travis included were correct. He just needs to slide in Ford at PG, Rosenthal at PF and Hansbrough at C in his starting lineup.

monicabiddix 26 pts

I think it's also worth mentioning that of all the Tar Heel PGs, Phil Ford is the only one with his jersey retired

MandMSportshow 34 pts

Charlie Scott, was he considered in this?

TravisSuttles 5 pts

MandMSportshow You bet. Charlie Scott would have been a lock if the roster had been just a little bit deeper. He was undoubtedly an great basketball talent, but with guys like MJ and Vince Carter both being eligable for the shooting guard spot, he was edged out.

MandMSportshow 34 pts

I must say that any list that Begins with PG and the name Phil Ford is not attached is a miss in my opinion. I had the pleasure of working for Coach Ford for a period of time, and watching him mostly in replays. having seen Ed Cota up close and I think his ability to lead a team was very good even he was no where in Phil Ford category. Kenny Smith however has put on the best dribbling ball handling clinic I have ever watched.

KIH Matt 37 pts moderator

MandMSportshow

I love Cota as well but I put Ford, Felton, Lawson, and Smith ahead of him.

ToddGreene 15 pts

If Phil-freaking-Ford doesn't make Any top heel list,regardless of criteria you have lost the ability to see,think and otherwise function in this world. And no Hansbrough? If reddick makes dooks list over the likes of ....well, a two guard from escapes me(Ricky Price, Trajan Clangdon was as far as I got). Your qualifying seemed a bit hit and miss to me. But that's what makes each of us passionate about our experience as a fan. I still love George Lynch and wish Joseph Forte had stayed. The real travesty here is the omission of...wait for it...Taymon Domzalski!! or Shavlik Randolph. I could go on but you get it. GO HEELS!

TravisSuttles 5 pts

ToddGreeneMandMSportshowmonicabiddix I gave Ford a hard look when I put together this team. His contributions while actually attending UNC were defiantly superior to that of Kenny Smith. In the end, it came down to the career statistics. Smith has 9,397 points (to Ford's 5,594) and 4,037 assists (to Ford's 3,083). He also won two Championships with the Rockets. I know that Ford is the bigger name for Tar Heels fans, but I though that the statistics pretty much spoke for themselves.

ToddGreene 15 pts

TravisSuttles MandMSportshow monicabiddix sorry bout the empty post. Man, I hate to call you on this but you said nothing in this article about the nba. But, now that I understand, here goes. James Worthy is the starter at sf. Only mj had better combined college and pro numbers. As far as respecting Kenny's rings-Scott Williams has a few. So just because Kenny played with Hakeem when Jordan played baseball he gets the nod? Phil Ford played before the shot clock and 3 point line and was the nba rookie of the year. I know he got hurt and his nba career wasn't as long as Smith's but he is hands down the very best point guard Chapel Hill has ever seen. Okay. I will agree to disagree from here on this.

TravisSuttles 5 pts

ToddGreeneMandMSportshowmonicabiddix Alright, I'll be totally honest and admit that it would have been beneficial to include a short list of my qualifications for this list. All of the players have short list of accomplishments and reasons that they made my list though, and all of them do specifically mention the NBA. As far as the Smith/Ford debate is concerned, I still give smith the nod on my personal rankings, but I will defiantly respect your opinion on the matter. At the end of the day, both of those guys had awesome careers, and both are deserving of their accolades. In the end, I think it comes down to personal opinions as much as anything.

ToddGreene 15 pts

TravisSuttles MandMSportshow monicabiddix I can see you did do your homework here. Nuthin but love for a fellow Heel. We have bigger fish to fry, like Feb. 3rd.

TravisSuttles 5 pts

ToddGreeneMandMSportshowmonicabiddix Right back at you man. Defiant respect for your knowledge (And everyone else's for that matter. I have thoroughly enjoyed getting to talk about some of the Tar Heel legends from the past. Now lets see if the guys from the current can add their names to this list.

TravisSuttles 5 pts

I see both of your points here. When I said that UNC didn't have many point guards to choose from, I meant in comparison to the other positions. Compared to other major schools, UNC's production at the point has been stellar. Few programs can boast talent like Smith, Relying and Lawson. Fromna statistical standpoint, their just wasn't a player that dominated in the same way as the guys at the other positions.
As far as Hansbrough is concerned, it killed me not to put him on i team. However, I based these rankings on the players entire basketball career (sort of like the pro basketball Ballot Fame resume). Don't get me wrong, Hansbrough is undoubtedly one of the best talents to ever come through UNC, and would be the first player on this list if those were the only criteria. But I'm afraid that he might have peaked as a NBA player. With these younger players I had to do my rankings based on projections for the rest of their careers. I just don't see Hansbrough become much more that a high energy big man that teams bring off the bench. Im glad that you guys, because the fact that his colligate career was so special that he's drawing legitimate consideration shows just how impressive his tenure with the Tar Heels was. I just couldn't move him ahead of guys like Worthy or Jamison.
I was able to put Reddick on Duke's roster, mostly because the overall talent pool was not as high. In this case there were no players of Jamison's level who were deserving of a spot. I also felt as though Reddick's potential as a pro outweights that of Hansbrough. With his elite shooting ability, I think that he could have the more productive career.

KIH Matt 37 pts moderator

TravisSuttles

dude Hansbrough is playing some good basketball for the Pacers right now. Being the all time leading ACC scorer he's a starter along with Rosenthal down low. Jamison, Worthy those guys come off the bench.

monicabiddix 26 pts

Rosenbluth matt hamm I have to agree. Hansbrough MUST be on the list. And the Heels have plenty of PGuards to choose from. The Jet would be hands down winner with any other school. Smith arguably had the best NBA career (thus far) of UNC PGs but yeah Phil Ford was one of the greats. And I don't know Raymond Felton always has a special place in my heart. I think it was the steal in the 2005 Championship. For Duke, how did Cherokee Parks not make the cut, j/k.

KIH Matt 37 pts moderator

monicabiddix

Felton was such a special player. It's great seeing him and Lawson succeed in the NBA. I wish they would have remained teammates in Denver though.

KIH Matt 37 pts moderator

great read and I agree Carolina kills Dook in any matchup. But you missed on picking the roster IMO. PG-Phil Ford PF-Len Rosenthal C-Tyler Hansbrough. Ford is one of the best PGs in ACC history and was UNCs all time leading scorer for a long time. Tyler is the ACCs all time leading scorer and Rosenthal (spelling?) is one of the greatest Tar Heels ever. In 57 his UNC team defeated Wilt's Kansas squad.